Ok, for those who asked - my evaluation after 1 hour of playing my new SD-50
summary
1. tone / sound - magnificent, outstanding, best I've ever heard
2. playability - excellent ...1 7/8 neck - just what I needed
3. feel / comfort - easier to sit on couch with than my L-03R, not quit as comfortable as my classical but I knew that
going in, a 000 would match up closer to the classical
4. appearence- elegant, not overstated, think black evening dress and white peal neckless
5. construction - perfect as far as I can tell (I'm not a pro)
6. any dislikes / disappointments - yes - don't like the tuners
STOP HERE IF YOU HAVE ATTENTION DEFICIT DISORDER, heard enough, don't have time etc.. :bgrin:
=====================================================================
First, let me introduce you to Maggie. I decided to name her in honor of my Grandmother Peggie Margret Flatt.
Mahogony and Marget equals Maggie. My Grandmother was related to Lester Flatt of Flatt and Scruggs fame.
I never met Lester or my Grandmother. She died before I was born. I was told she loved to sing hymns while working around the house or on the farm. She raised 11 kids and survived the great depression while doing so on a farm here in Tennessee. The last child she had was at age 45 - that was my father.
1. tone / sound
This guitar is new. I'm sure it will only get better. Yet it sounds better than anything I've ever played. When shopping, I played a $4,000 Sata Cruze, a Gibson over $5,000 and a vintage Martin over $5,000. I like this guitar best. The reason I had an interest in getting a steel string was for the treble voice of steel - I like the sound of steel treble better than nylon. When I play some single note melody runs in the mid to high treble on this guitar she sings more beautiful than any guitar I ever heard. Clear, strong, sweet, bell-like. On chords, the overtones are so beautiful. This is the number one reason I wanted a steel string guitar. If an electric guitar could be built that sounded perfectly acoustic I think it would sound like this.
Larrivees are famous for balance. 'nuff said.
The sustain and volume on this guitar must be experienced to be appreciated.
I love the sound of nylon bass. I will probably never find a steel string that pleases my ear as much as my nylon bass. The bass on my SD-50 is brighter / clearer than my L-03R.
A wonderful surprise is that this guitar matches my singing voice better than the L-03R (rosewood). When I decided to get a steel string in search of that treble sound I like, I expected to use the steel just for instrumentals and to continue singing with the nylon. I'm finding that me and Maggie sound better together than the L-03R or classical. I will use the classical for working out arrangements, practicing scales and playing or singing songs that I use a lot of barre cords in or emphasize bass in. I see the SD-50 as my new singing partner and instrumental guitar.
2. playability - the 1 7/8 neck is perfect for me. I can articulate each note when I am playing areggios and doing melody lines. I never got used to the 1 3/4 neck on the L-03R. Going to 1 7/8 makes all the difference in the world to me. After 7 weeks with my L-03R I still buzzed and missed. When I picked up the SD-50 I played as if I was on my 2'' classical. I am a fingerstyle player with a soft touch. So the action on Maggie can be lowered some more and I think I will like it even better. After she settles in, I'll take her to Richard Starkey to make her perfect.
Not the Beatle, the former Martin employee who is now famous for repairs and pickin'.
I never got used to 14 frets either. The 12 frets on Maggie make me feel right at home. The body of the SD-50 is longer than the L-03 but with the shorter 12 fret board, the reach down to the nut is not quite as far as the L-03R.
After playing the 12 fret classical so long, it was not as comfortable reaching farther for open chords on the L-03R.
I like the slot head. For me, it makes a statement that I'm a fingerstyle player - although you can strum it just fine - its just not my style.
3. feel and comfort - more comfortable to me than my L-03R, almost as good as my classical. I'm 5' 8" so it might feel different to others. I have short but wide hands / fingers. I wear a size large thumb pick. The SD-50 is thicker than the L03R by a little bit and thicker than my classical by a lot. It still fits my laptop style ok. I find it easier to adjust to a thicker guitar than a longer one.
4. appearence - very beautiful. I prefer an elagant / simple / refined look - as opposed to elaborate inlays and other cosmetics. I would actually prefer a satin finish but the finish on this guitar is nice.
5. construction- I see no flaws whatsoever in this guitar
6. tuners - I do not like the tuners. I don't like the small pegs.
Can someone tell me if they can be replaced ? Maybe the tuners should be replaced ?
When I tuned the guitar to play it for the first time, the tuner for the G string gave me problems - don't know if the string slipped or what. Had to work with it a bit to get it right.
The tuners are a disappointment to me on a guitar of this quality and price. :crying:
CONCLUSION- when I decided to venture into the steel string world this is the guitar I imagined
(except for the tuners. Maybe there is a fix for that. Open to suggestions)
If you'll excuse me now, Maggie and I are going to spend some quality time together :bgrin:
Thanks for the detailed info- Welcome to the Fam, Maggie!
A new Larrivee - ho hum... How nice it would be.... Wait a minute! I just got a new one! It is my father's day, Christmas, and every other holiday gift!
Congrats LW - May you and Maggie have many happy days!
Aren't honeymoons sweet?! :humour:
You captured the SD-50 pretty well in your post. I've gotten used to the smallish tuners and am okay with them but they could be better, like some sort of butterbeans perhaps.
One thing I like about the SD-50 is how well strummed chords blend together. Another is how it doesn't seem to have wolf notes and plays/sounds great up the neck. Some people like how the 03 series guitars are so open-sounding when new compared to glossy finished guitars. The SD is open from the opening bell.
:gotpics:
Larry,
Congrats on your new baby......... :nice guitar:
There is a thread around here on swapping out the Ping tuners for some 3 on a plate Waverlies. I think it was Bhika did the swap on his 000-50, but the headstock on your SD-50 might be the same. They looked really good, but were kind of $pendy, as I recall. I rhink these were the ones
http://www.stewmac.com/shop/Tuners/Guitar,_slotted_peghead_tuners/7/Waverly_Slotted_Peghead_Guitar_Tuners.html
Wow, you've got a whole holiday weekend to get to know Maggie. Have a Grand time.
Gary
Gary, thanks for the ref about tuners.
I didn't spent this much on an excellent guitar to get inferior tuners. I will get this problem fixed.
- Larry
This might help
http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?topic=16002.msg145540#msg145540
I was pretty close to getting a SD50 myself :whistling:....it sounds like you have found a keeper. Thanks for the detailed review. You really put your experience with the guitar into words well. You make me want one!
Justin
P.S. Larrivee's poor quality tuner issue is a common rant 'round here as you may already know :winkin: Larrivee is beginning to put Schaller M6s on their "paddle heads" and they may be updating the slotheads in the near future as well. Who knows?
It is great when a guitar inspires you. Different guitars inspire me different ways. I think wider necks are cool and I could become a 12 fret man real easily (except I own 3 acoustic guitars and I am not planning on a fourth). Congratulations on the new addition.
good review of the SD-50. :nice guitar:
I love mine but woudnt be able to articulate why as well as you have.
Glad you are enjoying it. I don't mind the tuners on it @ all. they have been trouble-free on the 3 guitars I have had with them.
You got me going again (gas :nana_guitar). An SD Larrivee is what I want next in a guitar.
Thank you for the compliments and encouragement. The more time I spend with Maggie the more I like her.
I will research this tuner issue I have.
Does anyone know if just the pegs can be replaced ? I don't like the small pegs.
I'll post pictures once I learn how to do it. I downloaded a free program called infranview and learned how to resize images. From the HELP option here on the forum it looks like I must use the GIF format. Best I can tell, I must store images on an internet site somewhere in GIF format and then use the INSERT IMAGE option and provide the link addresss. I learned how to convert my JPG files to GIF.
Now I'm looking for a way to store them on the internet somewhere
Anybody have any suggestions on where to store images?
- Larry
You're making it too hard.
I just used Irfanview to resize the following photo to 500x200 pixels, saved on my computer. It is my SD-50 with new strings on it this week.
Click Additional Options below the reply window and click on Browse... and then find the file on your computer. You don't need a hosting site. So let's have the pix!
[attachment deleted by admin]
Ok, I'll give that a try.
This is my L-03R that I bought last month and promised to post pics once I learned how.
If this works then I'll take pics of Maggie and share them.
[attachment deleted by admin]
QuoteClick Additional Options below the reply window and click on Browse... and then find the file on your computer. You don't need a hosting site. So let's have the pix!
Thanks :thumb :donut :coffee I suspected there was an esay way.
These pics are not very good. The color on the outdoor shot is too yellow.
I'll try to do better with Maggie.
Now that I have Maggie, the L-03R is OFFICIALLY for sale.
Can anyone suggest a fair price for a 'new' (7 week old) L-03R that has been treated like a member of the house ?
- Larry
Hi Larry, I just read this thread and your one on waiting for it to get there. I hadn't checked here in a few days so I started from the beginning and read in the proper sequence. It was like a good short story, nice plot, suspense, a little mystery and a promise of PICTURES, Did I miss something? Are they posted somewhere else. I know you must be busy playing it. But we need to finish this little book. At least this chapter. Actually it is easier to post pictures than some of the ways that are used. If you need help P.M. me and I'll describe an easy way for you.
I went to a few guitar stores today to look at slot heads and 000 or smaller styles. The only Larri out of the usual line that I found was a D-60. It did not seem any different than my D-09. Except for a few minor issues. So I still have not seen a 00,000 or SD. Oh well at least I can look at some pictures. RIGHT? Thanks for the post. Happy playin, Danny :guitar
Congrats on the new SD, I am happy to know I am not the only one who thinks these are among the best guitars out there.
When my SD-60 was new I had a small tuning issue. The tuners have a high ratio allowing for very fine tuning that takes some time to adjust to.
Also make sure that the line between nut and the tuner is as straight as possible. Some strings may need to be wound on the tuning post from in to out while others may be out to in. Also make sure you put some graphite on the nut to relieve any string binding. Once I did these two things on both the SD & the O all my tuning issues disappeared. Both guitars not only stay in tune while playing, but are usually good to go coming out of the case.
Danny, the SD-50 pics have been posted in a separate post
http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?topic=21664.0
There was a delay while I learned how to do it.
...enjoy
my next goal is to learn how to post an audio clip.
- Larry
Thanks Larry, I did discover the pix, :nice guitar: Happy Playing. Danny