Regarding this thread:
http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?topic=20599.0
I've been playing with the Rohrtech Titanium strings for a month and here are my thoughts, as well as my personal opinion based on "my" preferences...
I ordered a set of Rohrtech mediums at the end of March. They arrived promptly in about a week and I strung them up. The only issue I had was that the instructions specifically noted to NOT cut the sheathed string ends off until fully installed. The sheathing prevents recoil of the windings both during storage, and during installation. However, the increased thickness of the sheathing would not fit through the tuning pegs. I forced a couple through, but one tore and one I had to remove. There was no way for me to get it to fit. Admittedly, this may be an issue with my guitar and the Gotoh tuners I happen to install. This is probably not a universal issue with their product.
They are what they say they are. Lower in tension, progressively tensioned, titanium strings that should last a good long time even with a player that has the most acidic body chemistry. As described, they were "bright" for an longer time period than most conventional strings. However, they did settle in.
I did lose some noticeable volume out of the guitar. Not sure if I can understand why. They have a thicker string on the low end when compared to the Newtone MC Med-Light (which are really more like Lights) set I normally use. But, I wasn't the only one who noticed it. I continued to play them thinking that once they settled in this may change, but it did not.
I noticed that I was more apt to overdrive the guitar in aggressive strumming situations. I'll define overdrive as the string making noise due to the extreme vibration buzzing on frets. A different set up would definitely change this, but if I have to raise the set up to get clean sound, it kind of defeats the purpose of getting a lighter tensioned string set to ease your chording.
I also had a little issue with the progressively tensioned strings. Admittedly, this is more than likely due to my playing habits. But, I found it more difficult to use a flat pick in rhythmic picking situations. Maybe I'm used to the rebound of the conventional higher tension in the middle strings, but I found myself not sounding too clean, almost tripping over strings instead of hitting them with precision. It could be more practice over time or (again) a different set up, but it felt "different" and I may have played too long for this old dog to want to learn new tricks.
All in all, a worthy experience. The Rohrtechs did play easier overall, but there were just a lot of little things that just didn't quite fit my style and I've changed back to the Newtone MC I was using previously. It reminded me of going on a date with someone you didn't have any chemistry with. No real reason why, she is good looking, nice, intelligent, etc, etc. But, you know it isn't going to go anywhere. But, I'm sure there's someone for her out there.
The one thing I noticed this evening when I changed back, which did concern me a bit, was fret wear. I didn't really think about it, but the titanium may (not real sure of the hardness factor) cause excelled fret wear. I did notice that a few of my frets needed light dressing on this string change, which has never happened before. I'll see what the new set does, but the guitar is too new to typically see this type of wear. However, it was light, it was just two frets, and I may be over analytical. It would be worth investigating though.
So, they weren't for me. Not that I want anyone else not to give them a spin. Especially if you might be willing to get a set up with once they have been installed. They advertise that a set up is not necessary, and again, it may be me and my style. I was instantly more comfortable with traditional stings. Less buzz, better precision, volume is back, etc.
Hope this helps... and try something new! You never know when you find something that works!
Dale--
Thanks for sharing your observations on the Rohrtech Titanium strings. It's always good to try new things. Based on thier price tag and your comments, I'm content not having to concern myself with issues like fret wear, string sheath wrestling and delayed response from a strong attack. It sounds like they might work for someone with a gentle fingerstyle technique though.
DAVE
Dave -- Just so I'm clear, the stings were not delayed as much as I was not precise in my picking technique because I was used to a more tensioned string that rebounded earlier. You are correct though, these are probably good for fingerstyle.
Just to reiterate, my guitar is set up with low action and was set up specifically for the Newtone strings I play. Going to lower tensioned strings, it may be a somewhat unfair review since most guitars may not be as finicky.
Dale-
Thanks for the clarification. It seems you have a good formula for your playing style with low action and Cleartones. If it ain't broke...
Quote from: ncognito on May 13, 2008, 06:41:37 AM
Dale-
Thanks for the clarification. It seems you have a good formula for your playing style with low action and Cleartones. If it ain't broke...
Cleartones?? No, I think you mean Newtones. The moral of the story seems to be that sticking with Newtone strings is best. They are my favourite strings, but as mentioned elsewhere on this forum, I prefer the extra tension of Martin SPs or D'Addario lights on my Larrivée Rosewood Parlor as they get the (quite stiff) top working more.