Main Forums => Technical Discussion => Topic started by: Tony Burns on April 11, 2008, 06:56:03 PM

Title: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: Tony Burns on April 11, 2008, 06:56:03 PM
I have a memory of a cleartone string ad - with a kid who put cleartone strings on his guitar and then it shows an old man with those strings on his guitar ( like its the same person )  I put Dadarrio EXP'S custom lights on my OMv60 6 months ago ( Oct ) they are dying or pretty darn near dead ( a few of the high strings refuse to give up the ghost  ) is 6 months about right - I'm not complaining , they were only a few dollars more and they lasted about twice as long as regular PB's - Now i bet your thinking" but their not cleartone strings" - what does that have to do with a kid and an Elderly gentleman ( I'm saying elderly gentleman because  some days i feel that old )    Whats your experiences with long life strings ? Is mine typical ?
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: jdimitri on April 12, 2008, 06:24:14 AM
For me.. probably 2 months tops

Uncoated- a week or two

The biggest problem is the plain strings rusting.. and the other ones 'browning'

The joys of acidic fingers..
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: ducktrapper on April 12, 2008, 08:39:28 AM
Oh it's the strings that are long life? Drat I was hoping they'd keep me going!
Seriously, as a non-exuder, they last me so long that I have to force myself to change strings whether they need it or not.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: Bltprf502 on April 12, 2008, 09:12:12 AM
I can use coated strings for 3-4 weeks tops.  With that said, I started using uncoated strings on most of mine.  If you are using any string for 6 months, you are playing a dead string.  My Cleartones were good for a couple of months tops.  The EXP's are good for maybe 4 weeks.  ELixers as much as I hate to say it are probablt the best coated string out there (Nanoweb).
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: ducktrapper on April 12, 2008, 09:55:54 AM
Quote from: Bltprf502 on April 12, 2008, 09:12:12 AM
If you are using any string for 6 months, you are playing a dead string. 

This is what I meant by having to force myself to change strings after, okay let's say, 6 months. If they still sound good, what exactly is wrong with them? Define using. Define playing. Define ... dead.  :arrow   
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: brandon on April 12, 2008, 11:01:27 AM
i'd say 6 months is about right. ive never got 6 months out of my strings but usually at the first hint of loss of sound or tone i'll change mine.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: Dale_I on April 12, 2008, 05:08:34 PM
Quote from: ducktrapper on April 12, 2008, 09:55:54 AM
This is what I meant by having to force myself to change strings after, okay let's say, 6 months. If they still sound good, what exactly is wrong with them? Define using. Define playing. Define ... dead.  :arrow   
:+1:  You're dealing with a subjective and individually defined item. Out of 10 people you will probably get 12 opinions. None of them will match yours...
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: jeremy3220 on April 12, 2008, 06:04:11 PM
The last set of coated strings I tried lasted a day then they got thrown in the trash. I can leave uncoated strings on for 2 or 3 months; my guitars are more than their strings. they don't need fresh strings to sound good.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: Novalis on April 12, 2008, 07:24:36 PM
Quote from: Tony Burns on April 11, 2008, 06:56:03 PM
Whats your experiences with long life strings?

My experience goes like this:
Coated strings don't sound good to my ears, thus the one set I ever tried didn't stay on my guitar long enough to wear out.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: 1ply on April 12, 2008, 07:49:37 PM
I hope they don't last a lifetime since I could not purchase life insurance.  The ads that feature a little boy and an older gentlemen are as realistic as the ads that promise me women chasing after me if I just use the right cologne.  Oh well, maybe its just me. :crying:

I use Cleartones on my 12 string guitars since they are more difficult to change.  I get about 3 months out of them depending upon how often I play them.  I also wipe them when I am done.

The Elixer polyweb last the longest but I don't like their sound.  The CLeartones have a coating on the steel strings but I don't believe that any of the Elixer strings do.

Peace,
Rip

Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: Blue in VT on April 14, 2008, 10:30:27 AM
My elixir nanoweb light pbs last for 4-5 months before they cry out for a change....a

Blue
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: DFR on April 14, 2008, 09:13:00 PM
My Newtones realistically last 3-4 weeks before they begin to lose volume and tone.  I usually leave them on a little longer because they ain't cheap.  I just love the way they sound when new (after settling in for a day).

Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: aboss on April 14, 2008, 09:46:26 PM
Lots of people say elixer nanos last the longest but don't sound good.

I personally love how they sound on my guitar.

It's all in the ear (and, i guess, fingers) of the guitar-holder. My fingers are pretty acidic i guess, so I go through strings quickly. I probably average 1-2 months on a set of nanos. When i tried cleartones they sounded great for about a week... then went dead really fast. Everyone's chemistry is different i guess.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: golfer on April 15, 2008, 10:05:05 AM
Elixer nano's for me last quite well.  2 -3 months render them pretty dead thouth even to my poor hearing.
  I think the time will very, depending on how much you use them, your hand oils, and how demanding you are on the tone of your guitar.
  I have read that some player change before every gig, like 3 times a week sometimes.  These probably wern't coated, but you get the picture.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: Calvin on April 16, 2008, 05:29:51 AM
Nano's last about 6-8 month.  But I have an asian man's finger and body chemistry. EXPs have only marginally lower longevity.  EXP's sound so much better than Nano's though.  Almost non-coated good.

Elixers are very tinny sounding strings if you ask me.  Too metallic, blehk.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: flip33 on June 17, 2008, 06:24:58 PM
I've enjoyed elixir nano 80/20 custom light strings on my L-03 and my Martin 000-15S. 

I tried them on my Blueridge BG-60 and they sounded too bright on the B and e strings.  They also sounded too bright and thin on my Sigma DR-41.  Daddario EXP19's were better for those guitars.

Also, about 8 months max for me with coated strings, and even then they are not horrible... just not as  chimey.
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: gluve1 on June 17, 2008, 07:14:25 PM


If a guitar is played  is played a lot there is definitely a difference  in about one month in three month a big difference. Most people  just don't notice it because it gradual. It like your kids Some one don't see them for a few months and will say man have they grown, but you don't notice as much. Change your strings once a month for about 6 months. then try and let them go six months you'll think your guitar sounds awful after three months
Title: Re: long life strings - How long do they really last ?
Post by: Quercus on June 18, 2008, 09:53:12 AM
I've tried a lot of strings and i continue to search for the good ones. In fact strings do not last longer and it's frustrating.
Newtones and Elixir seems to last longer because they sound flat when new, i hate these strings.
Actually i prefer d'addario EXP or regular, Martin FX and Ernie Ball.
Tommy Emmanuel told me to choose the strings your guitar likes and change brand often. If you keep always the same brand it will sound poor at a certain moment. Your guitar get used to strings !!!?? (sorry for my poor english)
I think it's better to change strings each month for me.