Has anybody heard of these guitar strings and given them a try on their Larrivee. Suppose to last a lot longer and not rust compared to regular acoustic strings.
http://www.rohrtech.com/
Thanks
I've never had a problem with rust as they wear out way before they can rust. They seem pretty pricy, so I'll stick with my Newtones as I love the sound and feel of them. I would like to hear though if anyone has tried them and what they think of them.
John
I have used them and they are great strings. They last and sound good as advertised. Eventually the string will wear through the winding and physically wear out. I had a set on my L-03 for about a year until the G string wore through at the 2nd fret. My biggest problem is no medium gauges.
Well, I could not afford a titanium bike, maybe I'll go for the strings......
Got my attention! May be a candidate for my Taylor T5C2-koa 12 string. I have been using acoustic 10-50 Thomastik which are fine but Taylor recommends electric strings for the alloy content and it's response for the magnetic pick up. I don't care for the tone or the feel of the electric string sets at all. Maybe the titanium content would produce the benefit of the alloy response with the acoustic tone? For those who have used them, how do they compare to a good acoustic string tonally?
too rich for my blood. website looks kinda retro though
I liked the sound tone, I really liked the fact that they sounded pure for a long time.
I got an e-mail back from them, they don't make a 12 string set, and the pickup systems won't "see" titanium, big bucks too. 3 strikes, they're out. Oh well :ohmy:
Quote from: AtlasHeating on March 18, 2008, 01:52:06 PM
My biggest problem is no medium gauges.
All I found listed on their site was Medium sets. Both in Nickel and Phosphor Bronze with and without low tension.
For the titanium not working with pickups, the only pickups that would be affected would be magnetic pick ups (humbucker or single coil styles). Any under saddle, under bridge, or mic system should work just fine.
If your stings are wearing out fast, corrosion or not, I'd say these might be good to try. I've been using Newtone's, but I do have an acidic nature and my strings feel the punishment. I'll give them a try. I'm always up for something new. Someone has to see if they are lying....
Their Medium is really light. Kind of like DR strings.
I just looked at D'Addario, Cleartone, Newtone, CF Martin, DR, Elixer, and compared them to the Rohrtech. Although I would put the Rohrtech on the lighter side of the medium gauges (by .001), I couldn't classify them as lights. I currently have Newtone Med-Lights and they are definitely heavier than the mid grade between light and medium, but are only .001 off on what most companies call their mediums.
A secondary thought was this, if they truly provide a lower tension for the same pitch, you really don't want the mass increasing too much. You would likely end up with string slap forcing you to raise the action. More dangerous when moving to lesser mass strings is the affect on sustain. However, the Rohrtech sets do have a larger diameter low end compared to the Newtone Med-Lights I'm currently strung with. So, I'll hope I would gain and not lose sustain. We'll see....
When you compare the tension, they are lights. Because they are using different materials the strings will be a bit thicker but the tension is light gauge. That being said, they did not work well for my Martin Dread, but did work well for the Larrivee L-03.
Quote from: AtlasHeating on March 25, 2008, 04:47:47 PM
When you compare the tension, they are lights. Because they are using different materials the strings will be a bit thicker but the tension is light gauge. That being said, they did not work well for my Martin Dread, but did work well for the Larrivee L-03.
I guess I'm missing your point. The whole purpose of using the different materials is to lower the string tension, which would allow for easier fretting and better playability, without reducing size. Keeping the similar size should retain volume and sustain and lowering the tension would make it better to play.
Because of the material, titanium and nickel, they admit to having a longer "bright" period during break in. Once broken in, their claim anyway, is to have an extremely long usable period where the string does not reach "the dead zone". The materials should give a larger advantage to those who are forced to change strings a lot due to body chemistry, but I can't see that as a disadvantage to those that don't have a higher acidity issue either.
Part of my "real job" I design air flow characteristics for turbo diesel engines. I read the diesel performance forums with one eye closed because most of the opinions are stated as fact with very little physics or understanding of such needed. Repeated enough, others start stating them as facts and they take on a life of their own. All to say, I tend to try to provide actual facts when available to hopefully stop the insanity of opinion, and requiring fact from others when able.
However, transferring that to my passion of guitar is not all that successful. Largely because guitar is a function of the senses. What you like to hear, what you like to feel when playing, and any matter of the senses are largely a matter of individual opinion. As well, what works for one, may not work for another. Given the subjective nature, any variety of opposing facts, let alone opinion, can coexist at any given time with equal validity.
I only bring this up for an intro to an apology to AtlasHeating. Rereading my last posts it seems (to me) that I am opposing your statements. I heartfully apologize. I am not invalidating your experiences and I hope I didn't offend you.
That said, here is what I got back from Newtone. "...our Master Class .012-.052 are 157lbs compared to our Heritage .012-.051 are 131lbs...", Neal Silverman
The Master Class .012-.052 are the Med-Light set I currently use. The Heritage set is their "low tension" strings specifically designed for vintage instruments. I was going to use these as a base line, along with some other generally used strings I read about on this forum, for a comparison. So, here is some info on string thickness and tension that I was able to collect.
Company defined Medium string sets:
Rohrtech titanium/nickel: .012 .016 .026 .034 .044 .055
Newtone Master Class: .013 .017 .026 .036 .046 .056
D'Addario Ph/Br: .013 .017 .026 .035 .045 .056
Elixir : .013 .017 .026 .035 .045 .056
Cleartone: .012 .016 .025 .033 .043 .053
Company defined Med-Light sets:
Newtone Master Class: .012 .016 .024 .032 .042 .052
Company defined Light string sets:
Newtone Master Class: .011 .012 .018 .026 .036 .046
D'Addario Ph/Br: . 012 .016 .024 .032 .042 .053
Elixir: .012 .016 .024 .032 .042 .053
Cleartone: .011 .015 .024 .032 .042 .052
Company defined low tension sets:
Rohrtech titanium/nickel: .0145 .0155 .024 .032 .042 .0525
Newtone Heritage: .012 .016 .020 .028 .038 .051
Cumulative tension rates:
Newtone Heritage: 131 lbs
Rohrtech Low Tension: 147 lbs
Newtone MC Med-Light: 157 lbs
Rohrtech Medium: 160 lbs
D'Addario Ph/Br Light: 163 lbs
D'Addario Ph/Br Medium: 189 lbs
I didn't include stings I couldn't get tension rates on except for the Elixir since I see so many posts with people using their stings and Cleartone since that is what comes on a stock Larrivee. So, what do I take away from all this?
Rohrtech Mediums appear to be more of a medium or medium light, but not a light. Even the sting tension is not out of the range for what you would find in Phosphor Bronze Mediums, although on the light side. It also appears that the Newtone Master Class Med-Lights are more of a light when compared to the diameter of most other manufacturer's sets.
It appears that the claims of Newtone having lower string tension due to the use of round cores it true. However, it also appears the Rohrtech has an advantage over round cores in string tension rates. Since the Rohrtech "low tension" set is almost exactly the same diameter as the Newtone Med-Lights and they came across with 10 lbs lower total string tension. Rohrtech Mediums, which are far more "medium" than the previously mentioned Newtone M/C Med-Lights (which should be Lights), are only 3lbs more in accumulated tension.
So, titanium or round core seems to have an advantage in string tension for the same diameter size over conventional strings with a slight nod to the titanium. If the titanium hold a longer usable life, they may be better deal. However, they would have to last as long as the percentage they are more expensive because I could purchase 2 sets of Newtones for the price of 1 set of Titanium Nickel. Will they last twice as long???
NEW THING I LEARNED: Wound strings have the opportunity to unravel, leaving the sting "dead". The ductile coatings used in the manufacture process yield over time to corrosion and deterioration of the coating due to vibration. Eliminating these will lead to a longer lasting string that will not go "dead" as quickly. Probably why an acidic nature will deaden stings and also why coated stings go from live to dead very quickly.
NEW THING TO THINK ABOUT: I was reading where progressive sting tension, where the sting tension almost stays the same between strings, makes the guitar play "better". You actually want the tension on the lower noted string to progress ever so slightly. It makes sense once you consider thickness, diameter, and vibration. I just never thought about it. Rohrtech is the only company with a progressive tension string package, albeit their low E does not follow this pattern. By The Way: I didn't read about progressive string tension on the Rohrtech site, it just happens that I noticed their tension charts followed the theory.
Just recieved an email back from Rohrtech. They confirmed that since the Titanium Nickel has a low magnetic signature, especially the G string which is also low in mass, does not work well with magnetic style pick ups. For acoustic players, that would mean a pickup like the LR Baggs M1 would not work.
However, the under saddle or under bridge like the LRB Element, LRB iBeam, LRB iMix, or mic would all work fine. I called LR Baggs just to make sure, and they confirmed. They said they even use the non-magnetic pick ups in classical nylon stinged guitars with no problem. My orders is going in, I'll let you know what I think after playing on them for a while.
Dale,
when you posted the total tension of different sets, the D'Addario medium gauge (189)was well above the Newtone (157)or the Rhortech (160). All I am saying is they do not have anything with 189 pounds of tension. Less tension = less sound on my Martin. They worked great on my L-03.
I really hope you like the strings.
Thanks for all the responses. It was much more informative than I had hoped for. Can't wait to see some detailed reviews on the strings. :nana_guitar
Quote from: AtlasHeating on March 27, 2008, 10:00:50 AM
...when you posted the total tension of different sets, the D'Addario medium gauge (189)was well above the Newtone (157)or the Rhortech (160). All I am saying is they do not have anything with 189 pounds of tension. Less tension = less sound on my Martin.
I think I might be confused again. If you are stating the D'Addario does not make a string with 189 lbs of tension, I got the tension figures from their own site. The D'Addario Phosphor Bronze Medium set is listed with these tensions:
27.4, 26.3, 35.3, 36.8, 34, and 29, which add to 188.8 lbs of accumulated tension.
http://www.daddario.com/DADProdDetail.aspx?CodaID=584&ID=2&Class=ABPA
In fact, more surprising to me, because I expected the medium sets to be higher in tension than the similar round core or titanium, is that even the light set of D'Addario was a higher tension than the medium set of Rohrtech.
The point of round core strings and/or titanium core strings IS to reduce tension. They should be less than a normally constructed string value for the same thickness. The equation of less tension equaling less sound on the Martin can't really be made absolutely. There is so much more than tension that creates volume in a guitar. Mass, density, frequency, winding process, winding material, wound tightness, etc. In fact, this is easily experienced in the fact of dead strings. Same materials, same mass, same tension, same sting, yet they lose volume and brightness. After reading about string theory, I would guess it has to do with the winding tension and how vibration and corrosion break down and deteriorate the strings ability to obtain a beneficial frequency.
But, that is the whole purpose of trying different materials and construction processes. Aside from the obvious longevity issue with corrosion.
But, please, don't shoot the messenger. As I said before, I am not hear to offend you or your experiences. I just posted the factual information I found. There are plenty of times that the reality of facts don't appear to have anything to do with personal subjective experiences.
Who knows? I may not like the way they feel and just go back to something I enjoy more...
Quote from: Dale_I on March 25, 2008, 07:16:04 PM
The whole purpose of using the different materials is to lower the string tension, which would allow for easier fretting and better playability, without reducing size. Keeping the similar size should retain volume and sustain and lowering the tension would make it better to play.
There is so much more than tension that creates volume in a guitar. Mass, density, frequency, winding process, winding material, wound tightness, etc.
Is this correct? What does the size have to do with volume and sustain? I always saw those as attributes of the tension the strings place on the soundboard; and that string size was related, mechanically, to the desired root note and tension.
The second quoted paragraph would seem to hold true for ELECTRIC guitars and the interaction with magnetic pickups.
I find this all interesting. I will state myself once again. I use medium gauge strings on my Martin HD-28. For THIS guitar, I prefer medium gauge strings like D'Addario EJ -17 .013 -.056. The Rhortech strings are really Light gauge strings according to the total tension (DR also calls light gauge medium). My experience has confirmed this. I really like the strings even though they are a bit pricey they are good. I can not use them on the Martin they won't drive the top.
DISCLAIMER: I AM NOT a luthier, string engineer, etc, etc. If you want to talk air flow on a diesel engine, turbo's, fueling characteristics, or the like, I'm your guy! I'm only relating what I have read and trying to apply the stated facts to what is being claimed and trying to make sense of it all.
saffron_boots -
There are many variables when looking at how a sound is made on a stringed instrument. Laying aside wood types, the guitars construction process and materials, and concentrating on string differences only... the relationship betwee string length, mass per unit length, and frequency (also could be defined as pitch) are dependant on tension to reach a desired harmonic. You can somewhat understand it this way...
Given the same mass, the longer the string, the higher the tension to achieve a frequency.
If the strings length is constant, the higher the strings mass, the higher the tension required for the frequency.
There is actually a formula that relates this. The formula looks pretty formidable, but it comes from the fact that the note produced by a string is proportional to the speed that sound travels in the string, and that speed in turn depends on how tense and how heavy the string is.
As you can see, mass and tension affect frequency and are somewhat tied. However, if the construction process of the string affects the mass, you would also affect the tension to reach the desired frequency. So, if you are dealing with a solid core string (like the 1st and 2nd), if the material has the same mass, the thicker the string the higher the tension required for the same note.
When you deal with wound strings, how tightly the winding process and what they use to wind around the strings will affect mass per unit length, therefore affecting required tension for frequency. For instance, a winding around a core string that is tighter will affect mass and tension. Round wound or flat wound will affect mass and therefore tension. Etc, etc, in all the varying configurations. Some tension is created in the winding and therefore adds to the total rate. All very confusing.
So far, we have only spoken to reaching the SAME frequency. We all know that guitars utilize different frequencies on each string. Depending on the tension for the mass of the given length, volume and sustain can be affected by either the mass or the tension, but also by the transmission of the frequency to the guitar (which is wear bone or tusq conversations can start). Also by what they are being transferred to (Spruce or Cedar, Rosewood or Mahogany, etc).
For any particular guitar there will be a harmonic or vibration that can be more resonant. String size is related, mechanically, to the desired root note (frequency) and tension. However, the harmonic vibration of the sting mass for a given length under tension is also related to the string volume and sustain, which can obviously be different for any guitar (dreadnaughts produce more volume than parlors) and for each type of transition material and wood type.
So, for a heavier gauged string set, you should theoretically get a longer sustain at a given volume. As you go lighter, you should experience less sustain at a given volume. As long as the string construction and materials remain the same. Hopefully you're not as confused as I am at this point :?)
You are correct in assuming that the string material and the interaction with pickups is more problematic with electric guitars. However, there are some pick ups used in accoustics that depend on magnetic properties, such as the LR Baggs M1, which is an ultra modified humbucker style sound hole pick up.
Atlasheating -
I think I figured out why I have been confused a little with some of the statements. You are defining light and medium as tension amounts and I am using the term "light gauge" or "medium gauge" as terms for the diameter of the string sets. In metal, gauge refers to the thickness of the material. I was assuming that gauge, in string terminology, would refer to the thickness of the diameter of the sting.
Obviously, dependant on the string material, core shape, winding type, winding amount, winding tension, etc, you can have varying masses for the same thickness (or gauge), which would require various tensions to reach frequency. Throw in we are now working with different metals, titanium and nickel instead of steel and phosphor bronze, you change everything up again.
One more twist... not every company uses the same gauge thickness per defined set. One company may call 10's light and another may say 10's are ultra-light. Sort of why, even though Newtone classifies the Med-Light that way, I would probably put them in the Light category based on the gauge thickness they used and how it matches, almost exactly, what other companies identify as Light.
I might suggest, for the purpose of this discussion, that we use gauge thickness to identify Light, Medium, etc and not tension amounts. One, because it seems to be more univerasally the industry standard. And, two, because it may be easier to define material or construction differences for the same gauge thickness and how it affects mass and tension and how it will relate to pitch.
If it is easier to end up with the same string mass and reduce tension to keep fretting easier without affecting sustain and tone by using more technologically advanced materials that interact with tension differently, I'm up for it!
Dale you have really thought about this. I really hope these strings work out for you!
I am more of a trial and error guy when it comes to strings and most are cheap enough to experiment with and not break the bank.
Please post when you have used these strings and let us know how you like them.
I tried the Ti strings twice and hated them both times. In addition to their feeling sticky and sounding slack, the B string broke within one week both times.
AtlasHeating - I'm a trial and error too, but a bit of a technology junky and like to see how new stuff works. Being somewhat of an engineer, I love the "theory to production" process. However, all to often, what works in theory never really materializes in practice. Pertinant to Titanium, since it's properties are different, it is bound to sound different as well. If nothing else, I wasted $25. In the grander scheme of things, not a huge loss and there are things much more detrimental I could be wasting lots more money on.
BobN - Bummer. The one thing I would not have expected was string breakage. I don't know enough about steel vrs titanium to know the properties of elasticity differences. In the same metal type, if you raise size and lower density your mass is affected and it would not be as "solid", if I can use that term.
NEW THING TO THINK ABOUT: Elasticity
We haven't talked about the properties of elasticity at all. As the sting changes unit length the diameter is also changed. The longer the unit length the small the diameter. As you strum, the string vibrates, and changes unit length. For this reason, new strings lose tension quickly as they "stretch" and need additional tension applied. The string will eventually normalize somewhat (what we call "stay in tune"). However, once in tune, we tend to think of the string as keeping the same diameter and not changing much. This is not true. It is constantly changing diameter as the tension is increase, decreased, increased again, in the playing process.
In the engine world we call a metal piece returning to a normalized position "memory". Such as a spring returning to its tensioned neutral postion. Different metals have different memory properties. You don't want too much density or you don't end up with movement, you end up with breakage. Ex: Grade 8 hardened bolts are actually fragile and have very little give. High in tensile strength, low in shear strength. Grade 5 hardened bolts are less in tensile strength, but higher in shear strength.
A string has to bridge both of these worlds. It has to hold high tension well while subjecting itself to memorized elasticity and still not break. Not a real easy task, and probably why string technology hasn't changed much in the last 100 years. From BobN's comment, I wonder if Titanium won't hold up under these parameters?
OK. Let's look at it this way:
An acoustic guitar is a Helmholz resonator. We hear tones because the soundbox vibrates and moves the air that's both inside and around it. The soundbox vibrates because excited strings are mechanically coupled to it via the bridge. The amount of air moved by the strings themselves, to create sound, is insignificant compared to the soundbox. i.e. Play a solid body electric guitar like a Les Paul unplugged. It's minor.
On an acoustic guitar, play the open 6th string note (E). Detune it to A. Play the 5th fret (E). Same mass, same frequency. Volume goes down. Why? Lower tension results in a less efficient transfer of energy into the soundboard hence it doesn't vibrate as much.
To counter the loss of energy with lower altered tunings we've increased scale length of specialized guitars from 23-26" to 27-30" just to bring the tension back up and have comparable volume to normal guitars.
There is a delicate balance with tension though: too much and you prohibit the soundboard from vibrating efficiently. To the effect of less, muddy bass and lower volume. Classical guitarists have had to deal with this for over 100 years. They get really fussy with their strings; to the point of mixing and matching sets and brands to find the right balance of tone and volume between the strings on their particular guitar.
I think string manufacturers have focused a lot of energy (pardon the pun) on creating a more efficient string (new materials, winding techniques, etc.). One that's easily excitable with minimal input from the player. Hence they ascribe virtues of them being louder, more sustain, etc. But put them on a crappy, inefficient guitar and I think the effect is lost.
"But put them on a crappy, inefficient guitar and I think the effect is lost."
That's why we put them on our Larrivees,