Main Forums => Larrivée Guitars => Topic started by: smw17 on December 14, 2006, 08:29:24 AM

Title: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: smw17 on December 14, 2006, 08:29:24 AM
I'm really interested in an OM and have been looking into the 03 Series, but I must confess that I've got a few reservations about the satin finish (never owned a satin finish guitar before).  How durable is the finish?  Does it hold up with normal "wear and tear"?

Any opinions/advice regarding mahogany vs. rosewood?  I've always leaned towards rosewood with dreads, but I've talked to a lot of OM players who seem to prefer mahogany.  Thanks.
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: tuffythepug on December 14, 2006, 10:57:22 AM
Hello SMW17 and welcome.  I've just recently acquired an OM-03R which is my first Larrivee guitar.  I too, had some reservations about the satin finish.  I recently sold a Martin D-15 all mahog. guitar which also had a satin finish and I wasn't crazy about it.   However, the OM-03R is absoultely beautiful in its satin finish.  Others on this forum have posted methods of buffing and polishing these guitars to make them look more like the standard gloss finish found on most guitars.  They look beautiful as well.  Check out previous posts on this subject to se photos of the finished product.  They look great but require quite a bit of work and involve some inherent risk.
I don't know how the  satin finish will hold up over time since I've only owned this OM for a couple of weeks. I still may go for the polish and buff but for now I'm totally involved with the sound which is amazing.  I certainly wouldn't let the satin finish scare me away from a fantastic guitar in every other respect.
For what it's worth......

Hope you are happy with your choice whichever way you go.,

Lynn
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: bluesman67 on December 14, 2006, 10:58:15 AM
I have an OM-O3R.  I don't believe that a gloss finish lasts longer or anything like that.  If anything, a benefit of satin is that wear and tear, knicks and marks blend in and don't stand out like they do on gloss.  The rosewood sounds sweet, as does the mahonany.  You would be happy with either but it would be best if you can find both at a shop to play side by side and let your ears decide for you.  The O3 is my first satin guitar and the simple look of it is addicting. :guitar
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: bluesman67 on December 14, 2006, 11:02:33 AM
Here's the discussion string on an OM-03R owner that polished it to make it shine, complete with pictures.  I like mine just the way it is, but this looks good too.  http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?topic=14266.0  :nana_guitar
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: jwb on December 14, 2006, 11:03:45 AM
Welcome...

I don't own an OM-03 but I have had my eye on a mahogany one for a few weeks.  I've played it several times and I really like it.  Like you, I lean towards the rosewood sound and most of my acoustics are rosewood, but for the OM I prefer the sound of the mahogany.  It has that sparkle and clarity that just fits the smaller OM body...and I don't really miss the overtones.  

I have a satin finished LV-03 that is a favorite and the finish has held up as well as any gloss finish.  It may even be better in that it does not show the scratches and dings as easily as gloss, but I'm also very careful with my guitars and there's not much wear on this LV-03 even after a year of frequent use.  I like the sound of the satin finish, too.  It seems louder in comparison, maybe not as balanced as gloss, hard to explain...

You won't be disappointed if you purchase one, and the mahogany 03 series is being replaced with sapele, or at least that's the word on the street.  (Chime in here everybody if that's not the case :?)  So it wouldn't hurt to buy one soon!


Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: Denis on December 14, 2006, 11:17:17 AM
Quote from: jwb on December 14, 2006, 11:03:45 AM

You won't be disappointed if you purchase one, and the mahogany 03 series is being replaced with sapele, or at least that's the word on the street.  (Chime in here everybody if that's not the case :?)  So it wouldn't hurt to buy one soon!


Firstly, welcome to the forum smw17.  I would go with the mahogany OM but then I am a mahogany guy these days with an all mahogany parlor and an L-03.  It is true that the new standard 03 series is going to have sapele back and sides.  They are porobably already in circulation now.  The cutoff point for mahogany and beginning of sapele is ser# 90 000.  My 2 week old L-03 is less than 30 away from that so they've got to be out there now.  Larrivee does mahogany right...

Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: Redeemed on December 14, 2006, 11:44:23 AM
Welcome smw17!

Being an OM-03 owner, I'm more than happy with everything about this guitar... and that includes the satin finish.  In my opinion, the Larrivee satin finish is head and shoulders better than the Martin satin finish.  The satin finish found on Martin 15 series guitars feels cheap for some reason. 

Re: Hog vs Rosewood... I once owned a beautiful L-09 that had the typical sitka/rosewood sound.  It was a fun guitar with lots of guts, but I have to admit, I don't miss it much.  Now, if I found myself without my little OM-03 one day, I'd be in tears.  The OM-03 is a great guitar with lots of versatility... I'd grab a geniune mahogany one now before it's too late.


-dan
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: rrgguitarman on December 14, 2006, 11:49:56 AM
Welcome to the forum snw17, the 03 series is the best deal in today's market. The satin look has grown on me since I first bought my D-03 two years ago. Like you i've catered to Rosewood most of my life but, like denis said, Larrivee does Mahogany right! fantastic sounding instrument.
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: sixpickn on December 14, 2006, 01:01:09 PM
There are those who think the satin finish allows the wood to vibrate a bit more freely than gloss, showing up as greater sensitivity at lower playing volumes.  I'm not sure if it's actually thinner than gloss or not.  I have gloss, satin, and the old nitro-lacquer finshes on instruments, and within this collection the old lacquer and modern satin sound more open than modern gloss (at lower volumes).  ymmv.  no worries about satin holding up over time. 

Oversimplified, mahogany works well for harder chord strumming - stronger mids with fewer overtones.   Rosewood works well for for delicate fingerstyle, open tunings, with a diminished midrange, perhaps better suited for solo work.  It always comes back to the specific instrument's characteristics and what else you're accompanying.  Either one makes great music.

happy hunting and welcome to the forum.

Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: PortHueneme on December 14, 2006, 03:11:32 PM
Here's another wood in the mix. I have an OM-3K (thanks unclrob). The KOA is somewhere between the Mahog & RW in sound.
I like the look of the satin finish, the KOA looks so natural.
I used some 100% pure Carnuba (no silicones) on the top, it put a slight gloss to it.
The carnuba also does wonders on the guitar neck making sliding around really smooth.
I play this guitar both fingerstyle and strumming (with pick). It often goes with me to jams because it is a little smaller to carry
and sit and hold for several hours.
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: Old Geezer on December 14, 2006, 05:01:54 PM
Quote from: bluesman67 on December 14, 2006, 11:02:33 AM
Here's the discussion string on an OM-03R owner that polished it to make it shine, complete with pictures.  I like mine just the way it is, but this looks good too.  http://www.larriveeforum.com/smf/index.php?topic=14266.0  :nana_guitar

I'll admit, I like the way my OM-03R looks polished..it has a deep red-orange hue that didn't show through the satin finish. But, that's just a matter of personal taste.
I can't say that I notice any appreciable difference in the sound since it's been polished.
I also own an OM-03SP that I'll probably never polish. The wood grain shows just fine with the satin finish and the sound is just great.

Welcome to the group and fear nothing about the satin finish.

OG
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: Peter Cree on December 14, 2006, 05:28:50 PM
I've got an OM-03MT and love it.

I'm often pretty critical about performance of various guitar makes /styles etc.  But this one is very good.

I polish all my guitars.  Finishes are part of my living so I can say from a professional view that the UV poly is tough.   

Larri Om's chime.  Hope you will enjoy yours half as much as I do mine.
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: Celticjam on December 14, 2006, 09:10:29 PM
I have two Forum OM-03s.  A little different than the standard OM-03; these are twelve fret with abalone around the sound hole and pearl logo and both have a satin finish.  I have a mahogany topped and a spruce topped both have hog back and sides.  Both are terrific guitars and no worries about the satin finish.  Of the two, I prefer the mahogany topped one, exceptionally sweet sound but the spruce top is no slouch either. The satin finish is tough and stands up beyond normal wear and tear.

May there be joy in your "struggle".
Kevin
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: whiskeyjack on December 14, 2006, 09:52:09 PM
Welcome aboard '17 :wave

I'll just re-echo what others have said about the satin finishes.  There's quite a bit of finish on these guitars and you have no worries about the finish being so fragile.  My OM-03R six and twelve strings came out looking great after some help from my luthier's buffing wheel.
(http://www.voguehost.com/ims/u/whiskeyjack/Larrivee%20OM%2012/OM12%20lrbaggs%202.jpg)

(http://www.voguehost.com/ims/u/whiskeyjack/Larrivee%20OM%206/om6%20top%20r2.jpg)
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: sixpickn on December 14, 2006, 10:09:19 PM
wow, nice job!  that's almost unfair :niceguitar:
is that with or without polishing compound?
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: Gemnoc on December 15, 2006, 12:14:19 AM
Wow²!

The satin finish seems strong enough. But I have a bad habit of resting/rubbing my right palm on the top over the low E when I play with fingers (I play mostly with fingers). After one year, I've kind of "buffed" that small area on the top. The result of your buffing on these pictures is fantastic, I'm very tempted to do it on my LV!
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: sharkblues on December 15, 2006, 09:27:01 AM
I've had my Taylor 410 with satin finish for ten years and it has held up well and aged beautifully.  However, I'm a play at home guy and it has never been challenged from spilled beer, profuse sweating, or the outdoor elements of an active musician's life.

The finish on my L-03 is very close to that of the Taylor and not at all like the Martin D-15R that I ordered from and then returned to Musicainsfriend.com (because the finish seemed way too thin).

Have you contacted a good dealer, luthier, or Larrivee for advice?

Let me say I love my L-03 that I have had for 3 weeks.  My Guild D-55, Martin HD-28 and a bunch of other nice guitars have not been touched since I bought the Larry home.  In fact, I am so impressed with it that just 2 days ago I ordered one of the last mahogany om-03s from Trinity.  Actually you might ask Bill at Trinity Guitars. It was my first time buying from him, but I felt 100% comfortable as he didn't impress me as a salesmen first kind of guy.

If the satin finish issue is just too much, you might check out the Guild GAD 30R, really different from the Larrivee, but a nice guitar IMO.

Best of luck,

Steve
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: kwakatak on December 15, 2006, 03:12:23 PM
I've had my OM-03R for about 7 months now and am loving it. I played both the -03 and the -03R and was amazed at how loud and in your face the tone was on either one of these guitars.

In the end I chose the rosewood over the mahogany because at the time I was looking for more of a fingerpicking guitar for mellow tunes as well as something that would strum and resonate with overtones. I was struck by how well the OM-03R handled that the very first time I tried it. I especially like to tune it in DADGAD or any other tuning where I drop down the low E string. I also like how its tone "shimmers" up the neck, particularly with a capo.

OTOH, every so often I like to Travis pick some blues on it and I must say that I find that the rosewood is not well-suited for that. Going back I found that the OM-03 fit that niche nicely, though I admit that I could be just as satisfied with Martin 000-15 which is naturally a different guitar.

As opposed to the rosewood's note-blending overtone properties, I believe that mahogany has a drier more woody sound where notes maintain their same pitch and don't degrade into a resoant harmonic. For this reason I'm left with the (purely subjective and possibly inaccurate) impression that the OM-03 has less sustain and bass response than its rosewood version though I'd be happy to dismiss that impression. Each evoke different moods from me. I think of rosewood as being somber and reflective, whereas I think of mahogany as warm and intimate. 

One thing is for certain though, when it comes to mahogany/sitka I just like the L-03 better than the OM-03. That extra bass just seems to add something that seems to be lacking with a smaller bodied guitar. I don't if it's because I just find the OM-03 to be a little too stylized or that I already have an OM that I'm happy with and want something different. I chalk that up to normal indecisiveness associated with GAS though!  :arrow
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: whiskeyjack on December 15, 2006, 09:38:24 PM
Quote from: sixpickn on December 14, 2006, 10:09:19 PM
wow, nice job!  that's almost unfair :niceguitar:
is that with or without polishing compound?

Yes, buffing compound was used. . . .the expensive stuff. . .from Italy I think. 

Just a side note. . .     The buffing compound does sometimes create a toner effect on satin finishes.  Larrivee satin finishes leave the wood pretty much white at a distance.  Glossing yellows it some.  I was a little disappointed at first because I like the look of natural wood (satin finish).  Satin finishes provide that moreso than gloss finishes.

The main reason I buffed these out is because they both have pickups and I found the noise of satin-finish-friction against my chest very distracting.  Those pickups amplify that rubbing sound somethin' fierce.
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: jessz1 on December 16, 2006, 08:11:43 PM
And another wood here. I recently bought an OM-03 Blackwood and it is a great guitar. No regrets.
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: jeremy3220 on December 16, 2006, 08:40:37 PM
I think the satin finish hides the superficial wear and tear better, also you don't worry about smudges as much. My OM-03MT (2 yrs old) looks better than alot of new guitars you see in shops.

Cree, do you have pics of your OM-03MT polished?
Title: Re: Opinions from OM-03 owners wanted
Post by: paralentor on December 18, 2006, 08:38:08 AM
Several months ago I returned a recently purchased OM-03 for an OM-03R and it may have been based
on the cleartone strings.  The older rosewood I selected in the shop had elixr strings.  The 03R seemed
heavier and more solid than the hog too and that I appreciated for it's smaller size.  I'm used to dreads.